Investigations
Airport vendors exceeded street-pricing markup limits at major hubs
Alec Opperman compared receipts and menus across New York, Chicago, Denver, and Portland as concessionaires filed benchmark prices.
Across New York, Chicago, Denver, and other hubs, Alec Opperman compared airport menus to street prices and found markups that broke local caps on most of the items he bought. More Perfect Union documented the trip he began on Sept. 16 with videographer Evan Carter.
Roughly four in five large airports impose some form of street pricing, often allowing only a 10 or 15 percent markup over an outside benchmark. Violations can carry lease consequences, and former Consumer Financial Protection Bureau senior adviser Brian Shearer told Opperman that taking advantage of captive travelers can fit state unfair-practices and price-gouging laws even when the markup looks small.
At New York airports run by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, vendors may not charge more than 15 percent above the market rate. Opperman found a $19 avocado toast priced 46 percent above a Manhattan chain location and documented other items that cleared that margin by wide gaps.
Chicago advertises value pricing, meaning street price alone. Opperman paid $7.19 for bottled water at an Evolve store in O'Hare, a markup he calculated at nearly 95 percent against three nearby convenience stores, and found a Whopper marked up 61 percent. Cheetos and Chex Mix at the same airport topped outside prices by more than 67 percent.
The same brands kept appearing on receipts. HMSHost, owned by Swiss retailer Avolta, runs roughly a thousand North American airport locations. SSP America operates hundreds of brands in dozens of airports, including a LaGuardia Melt Shop breakfast sandwich Opperman priced 42 percent above the street. OTG drew enforcement attention in Denver in 2022 after a $27 beer.
Airports often require vendors to file price comparisons. Denver journalist Steve Staeger had already documented vendors citing distant McDonald's locations or other airports' Starbucks to set a higher base. An airport official Staeger confronted defended the practice by saying travelers wanted the brands and would pay.
After Staeger's reporting, some Denver concessions appeared to honor the 15 percent cap, but Hudson, also owned by Avolta, still charged Opperman 59 percent more than nearby stores for Smartwater, and 16 percent more than water sold in the same terminal.
Opperman tallied items that exceeded a 15 percent markup across his nonrandom sample and landed near 69 percent. Convenience chains, especially Hudson, accounted for many of the largest gaps.
He emailed price evidence to officials in Chicago, Minneapolis, and New York. Minneapolis said it would look into the complaints. The Port Authority reviewed five prices he highlighted and told him three were acceptable, including $6.89 for water. A spokesperson said comparing Hudson to a neighborhood bodega was inappropriate because Hudson is a specialty market and cited a luxury-mall pharmacy as an example of that category.
The authority made two airport restaurants pull a $19 avocado toast and an $8.20 bagel sandwich from their menus while it reviewed pricing. It said it had corrected roughly 40 price discrepancies since 2025 and requires low-cost We Value You items.
Opperman carried the receipts to a Port Authority board public-comment session and urged commissioners to tighten monitoring of multinational concessionaires.
At Portland International Airport, which advertises street pricing without a plus margin, he found only small discrepancies at McDonald's and Starbucks, including a 12 percent markup on a pumpkin spice latte.
Source video: Airport Food Has a Price Limit. We Tracked Down the Companies Breaking It