Investigations

Nicholas Nelson pleaded guilty to six Newnan murders

Ballistic testing tied casings from three crime scenes to one nine-millimeter pistol before deputies found three victims in a motel room officers had passed.

Cops Discover Motel Room Filled With Serial Killer's Bodies
YouTube / Dr. Insanity

In Newnan, Georgia, Nicholas Martez Nelson shot six people across three crime scenes in November 2020 before police arrested him in a motel parking lot. Dr. Insanity assembled 911 tapes, body-camera footage, and interrogation video from the Coweta County investigation.

The spree began with a home invasion on Steeplechase Drive on November 5, when Nelson forced his way into a residence and stole firearms and gold jewelry. Hours later, shortly before 8 p.m., officers responded to East Broad Street after callers reported gunfire. They found William Edward Bussie III and Kevin Duane Robbins with multiple wounds on the driveway and back porch. Eleven spent Winchester nine-millimeter casings lay in the grass.

Witness Sher Lyn Hayes told police that Bussie had argued days earlier with Riley Holloway over stolen bicycles. Investigators treated Holloway as their lead suspect. He walked into the police station, denied shooting anyone, and agreed to a gunshot-residue test while offering an alibi.

On November 6, guests at a Motel 6 reported shots from the room below. Officers questioned people in the parking lot, knocked on doors, and passed room 117 without entering. Three people were dead inside while Nelson hid among the bodies. Coweta deputies did not open the door until November 8, when Tangela Molden’s mother asked for a welfare check. They found Tangela Molden, Monte James Ballard, and Michael Lang shot to death, with nine-millimeter casings on the floor.

On November 7, Warner Mandrel Parks was shot twice in the chest in an Eastgate Apartments parking lot. A ten-year-old witness described a light-colored two-door car. Officers collected three more nine-millimeter casings matching the East Broad Street caliber. With Holloway already in custody, detectives turned to Nicholas Nelson, a felon neighbors recognized.

Motel surveillance captured a man in a dark hoodie parking a light brown Ford Crown Victoria outside room 117. Nelson’s car matched, and damage on the passenger side matched footage from Eastgate. Deputies found the Crown Victoria at a Red Roof Inn, recovered a mask, gloves, and live nine-millimeter rounds, then detained Nelson in the lot.

In an interview, ADA Matthew Swoope told Nelson detectives had video of the Crown Victoria at Eastgate immediately before the shooting. Nelson denied being there. A search of his room turned up jewelry from the Steeplechase break-in and a Taurus nine-millimeter in a storage closet.

Ballistic tests linked casings from all three scenes to the same gun. Nelson faced six murder counts by November 11, 2020. In February 2023 he pleaded guilty to 27 charges and told the court he could not give a rational explanation for the killings. Superior Court Judge Travis Sakrison sentenced him to six consecutive life terms without parole.

Source video: Cops Discover Motel Room Filled With Serial Killer's Bodies